Douglas Wolk:

There’s a certain sexed-up visual atmosphere that’s endemic to superhero comics; the way their characters are drawn is supposed to be not just attractive but viscerally appealing, to provoke a kind of somatic response. That’s why Superman and Captain America are tall and ripplingly muscled, why Catwoman and Elektra are curvy and ripped, why all the heroes wear skintight outfits, and — ideally — part of why both men and women find them fun to look at. But stripping everything but quasipornographic lust-puppetry from superhero comics’ women characters actually gets that principle wrong. It’s a deliberate attempt to repulse half of their potential audience, and to sell “collectibles” to people who like the idea of repulsing that half. And it’s embarrassing to anyone who loves what’s left of the superhero genre.

Via Bookslut.

Keith Phipps:

[Rise of the Silver] Surfer seems committed to leave anyone over the age of 9 out of the equation.

The nine-year-olds in the audience I saw it with did seem to thoroughly enjoy themselves. Me? Well, not so much.

Which is not to say there’s anything wrong, necessarily, with being a movie only nine-year-old boys are going to love. I’m just saying: I’m not a nine-year-old boy anymore.